TheProdigy

anybody sat n listened to out of space for a whole night i find it a bit of a statement (im mad) n i love prodigy well mostly old stuff out of space, breath n .... any way yeah big up prodigy one day i 2 wish 2 b as famous and musicaly powerful and influential as you guys (me,joe downie)

Thank you

I understand, today I listened to experience expanded, yet again. I really should make a tally chart

charlythecatsays wrote:

it's BREATHE
and yeah, it's a killer tune

Yeah it's fucking great when you go back to the old skool stuff after a lengthy absence.

Charly is one fo the best tune they ever made and it still stands up
but for the life of me cna never understand why the remixed it for the album????

prodigyoverload wrote:

In short, Charly got quite a lot of negative critisism from amongst others MixMag ("Did Charly Kill Rave?"). Liam Howlett did a remix of Charly and put that on the album instead because of this; it sounded darker, more mature, less like "kiddy-rave".

What!!!! There are 2 versions of Charly!!! If I am not mistaken I have only heard the remis then-I will have to go and chack my albums. What CD is the original on???

Em wrote:

There are more than two versions of Charly even.

Charly was the second single by The Prodigy; there are several versions of Charly on the various single formats. On the album Experience there is only the Trip Into Drum And Bass Version. On Experience: Expanded the Alley Cat Remix can be found as well.

For a full list of all official different versions of Charly, and all other tracks by The Prodigy as well, click on the link in my signature and browse to the Tracks section. Here you can also listen to sound clips of every track. You will need to have RealPlayer installed though if you want to listen to the sound clips.

Yeah it's ridiculous, in my honest opinion Trip into DnB is quite an awesome version (with my sub, that song nearly shakes my entire house down ).

Charly (Original Mix)
Charly (Alley Cat Mix)
Charly (Beltram says Mix)
Charly (Trip into Drum and Bass Version)
And... Charly Says Goodbye - if you can count that

Josso wrote:

Fake track which can only be found on I believe the Only For The Headstrong bootleg CD; they just cut a small part out of Charly. (That sounds bad hehehe)

Arie wrote:


Oh right, something in my memory said it was on Dirtchamber... nevermind

I thought the alley cat remix just sounds the same as the charly on their law album.

Is a bit of an annoying soung really apart from the trip into drum and bass version

Isn't there a 7" edit as well?

Yes the Charly on Their Law is Alley Cat, they've always prefered that one for some reason.

Josso wrote:
I have a track called Charly (Alley Cat 7'' Edit) on my computer, so yes. And isn't that the one in the video?

Yes indeed it is.