Home COMMUNITY FORUM
Welcome, Guest
Username Password: Remember me

Petition to XL Recordings, Liam Howlett
(1 viewing) (1) Guest

TOPIC: Petition to XL Recordings, Liam Howlett

Re: Petition to XL Recordings, Liam Howlett 6 months, 3 weeks ago #65451

netgem21 wrote:
memphis wrote:
netgem21 wrote:
The Noisia one is pretty great, possibly even better than the original.
I just had to login after like...5 years... to say no f.ing way. I love the Noisia remix, but toping the original? I can't see that happening... never... even if Liam tries to recreate it


Well yeah, screw it, I prefer it. And Liam plays it live now, so I guess he likes it too. I like it, you hate it, whatever. Not everyone has to like the same music, you know.
I didn't say I hate it, read again. Nobody has to like anything, agreed. Noisia did a great job with the track, not merely remixing it, but reworking it with the original samples and recreating it and it turned out awesome. They messed with the track for about 2 months which deserves a lot of respect and earned Liam's respect with him playing it live. All good. But I can't see Noisia's version standing out through time like the original has. Today it still sounds so edgy, heavy and ahead of its time. It just seemed silly to say a rework or a remix is toping the original. At the end of the day it's all down to opinions, innit?
  • memphis
  • OFFLINE
  • Posts: 1337
I WIll Heat Your Ear Off

Re: Petition to XL Recordings, Liam Howlett 6 months, 3 weeks ago #65452

memphis wrote:
netgem21 wrote:
memphis wrote:
netgem21 wrote:
The Noisia one is pretty great, possibly even better than the original.
I just had to login after like...5 years... to say no f.ing way. I love the Noisia remix, but toping the original? I can't see that happening... never... even if Liam tries to recreate it


Well yeah, screw it, I prefer it. And Liam plays it live now, so I guess he likes it too. I like it, you hate it, whatever. Not everyone has to like the same music, you know.
I didn't say I hate it, read again. Nobody has to like anything, agreed. Noisia did a great job with the track, not merely remixing it, but reworking it with the original samples and recreating it and it turned out awesome. They messed with the track for about 2 months which deserves a lot of respect and earned Liam's respect with him playing it live. All good. But I can't see Noisia's version standing out through time like the original has. Today it still sounds so edgy, heavy and ahead of its time. It just seemed silly to say a rework or a remix is toping the original. At the end of the day it's all down to opinions, innit?


I mean better than the original in the sense that I think it's better than the original. Doesn't mean it is, I just prefer it.
  • netgem21
  • OFFLINE
  • Posts: 52

Re: Petition to XL Recordings, Liam Howlett 6 months, 3 weeks ago #65457

Everyone needs to chill down a bit, Netgem is entitled to their opinion so lets all relax a little. I think as a whole we're all a little disappointed but we can't judge it yet, the Glitch Mob uploaded a video of them creating their remix and as GlitchHop goes it sounds amazing, a really unique genre there. Yes prodigy have used dub tones in songs such as Razor but really that is ragga not Dubstep, it's the same as Out of Space. Now this is where you'll all be like 'gayyyyy' but I was really hoping for a 3 minute edit of Narayan or something, I love that song to bits. I would have loved to get some more unheard potential B-Sides on there or even just 'The Trick' or something but oh well, it's being released, lets just leave it...
  • BMReynolds1
  • OFFLINE
  • Posts: 179
Moderators: fLiNtY, tomás, arie
Time to create page: 0.31 seconds